Skip to main content

Crime + investigation

Who Are the Cornell 7? A Timeline of the Allegations and Investigation

A civil lawsuit reopened questions about a 2024 fraternity house incident, the original police investigation and the university’s disciplinary response.

Getty Images
Published: November 16, 2026Last Updated: November 16, 2026

A night at a Cornell University fraternity house in October 2024 became the subject of a campus investigation, disciplinary hearings and, nearly two years later, a civil lawsuit that brought national attention to the case.

The former student, identified in court papers as Jane Doe, alleges that seven fraternity members raped her after she became intoxicated at the Chi Phi house in Ithaca, N.Y. 

The men, widely called the “Cornell 7,” deny wrongdoing. The lawsuit names Matthew Ingalls, Scott Kretzschmar, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Johnathan Newell, Scott Norris, and Diego Sarabia; a separate defendant, former Chi Phi President Orazio Petito, was later dropped after being incorrectly identified as the chapter’s president at the time of the alleged assault.

Local prosecutors initially declined to bring charges in 2024. But the lawsuit prompted a renewed investigation, now overseen by New York Attorney General Letitia James’ office. As of publication time, no criminal charges have been announced. The civil litigation and a separate review of Cornell’s response remain ongoing.

Interrogation Raw

Interrogation Raw

Stories of dramatic murders and serious crimes through gripping interrogations.

October 19 to 20, 2024: The Alleged Assault Occurs

Doe, then 20, visits the Chi Phi fraternity house after drinking at her sorority house and going to bars. Her subsequent civil complaint says fraternity members pressured her to consume ketamine, gave her additional intoxicants and subjected her to sexual acts without her consent. The complain includes a screenshot of an alleged fraternity Snapchat exchange inviting others upstairs for sex. The defendants dispute her account.

November 8, 2024: Doe Reports the Incident

With encouragement from friends, Doe reports the incident to Cornell University Police. The university temporarily suspends Chi Phi’s chapter for alleged student conduct violations. The report begins a process that will involve campus police and university disciplinary officials, whose findings and decisions later come under scrutiny. Chi Phi’s Cornell chapter subsequently closes and remains barred from campus.

November 15, 2024: Doe Signs a Police Statement

Doe signs a six-page statement prepared by campus police. She says she was OK with an initial sexual encounter but later refused a proposed foursome and hid under the covers when more men entered the room. She describes feeling too intoxicated to make decisions. “To me, that felt like coercion,” she says in the statement. District Attorney Matthew Van Houten later says his office relied on the signed statement when it decided against filing charges. In the longer police interview transcript, Doe makes a direct allegation that does not appear in the signed statement: “I can say with 100% confidence I was raped.”

January 14, 2025: Cornell Opens a Title IX Investigation

Cornell begins a Title IX investigation in response to Doe’s formal complaint, her lawsuit says. The university process examines alleged sexual misconduct under school policies. Its proceedings can result in discipline, including suspension or expulsion, but do not determine criminal guilt or replace a prosecution.

February 6, 2025: Cornell Forms Task Force

Kolikoff and Cornell Provost Kavita Bala announce the establishment of the Presidential Task Force on Campus Sexual Assault, "to focus on addressing and preventing sexual assault on campus – a serious and persistent problem, both nationally and here on our campus." The announcement says the task force will deliver a report that summer "that outlines evidence-based strategies for addressing sexual assault at Cornell, including a timeline for implementation, metrics for success, and a plan to institutionalize this work."

May 2 to 29, 2025: Cornell Holds Disciplinary Hearings

Cornell conducts at least 12 hearings concerning Doe’s allegations. Its investigation includes 50 interviews with 32 witnesses. A university report later obtained by ABC News records Doe describing disorientation after taking ketamine. “I felt like bait,” she said in the report. Cornell later says its disciplinary process resulted in expulsions and suspensions. It disputes suggestions that those involved faced no meaningful consequences.

November 4, 2025: Cornell Releases SARM Results

Cornell releases the results of the 2025 Cornell Survey of Sexual Assault and Related Misconduct (SARM), showing 35% of undergraduate women and 8% of undergraduate men reported experiencing nonconsensual sexual contact involving force or incapacitation since attending Cornell.

September 16, 2026: Doe Files a Civil Lawsuit

Doe sues Cornell, seven men, fraternity and sorority entities and other defendants in New York County Supreme Court. The 101-page complaint seeks damages and alleges sexual assault, negligence and other wrongdoing. It challenges the university’s supervision and response. The filing brings the allegations to a wider audience and prompts renewed examination of the original criminal investigation.

September 28, 2026: Prosecutors Reopen the Investigation

Van Houten publicly outlines plans to reexamine the case and pursue grand jury review. He maintains that the original statement did not describe criminal conduct warranting charges and says the lawsuit presents substantially different allegations. Doe’s attorney disputes that characterization. Cornell supports renewed criminal review while defending its disciplinary response.

September 30, 2026: Police Records Complicate the Prosecutor’s Account

The public release of additional police records intensifies scrutiny of the decision not to prosecute. Doe’s statement describes feeling too intoxicated to make decisions and says the encounters felt like coercion. Separately, reporting on her interview transcript shows she explicitly alleged rape. Van Houten says his office did not receive the full transcript during its original review.

October 1, 2026: The State Takes Over

Gov. Kathy Hochul appoints Letitia James’ office as special prosecutor, citing diminished confidence in the local district attorney’s handling of the case. The appointment transfers responsibility for investigating and potentially prosecuting the allegations to the state. James says the investigation will follow the facts and law. The order doesn’t itself bring charges against any defendant.

October 6, 2026: Cornell Names an Independent Reviewer

A special committee of Cornell’s trustees retains former U.S. Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates to lead an independent review. Her team will examine the university’s response to Doe’s case and its broader sexual misconduct policies. The review addresses institutional conduct and operates separately from the state’s criminal investigation.

October 7, 2026: A Defendant Challenges James’ Appointment

Gillio Lopes petitions to block James from serving as special prosecutor. His attorneys argue that a social media post supporting Doe before James’ appointment demonstrates bias. The challenge raises a separate legal question about who should oversee the criminal investigation. A hearing on the petition is scheduled for October 29.

October 9, 2026: A Judge Orders Filings Sealed

Justice Phaedra Perry-Bond orders several civil court filings sealed after addresses in the documents expose people to threats, including a family unconnected to the allegations. She directs Doe’s lawyers to submit redacted versions. The order addresses safety and personal information as public attention spreads beyond the courtroom.

October 16, 2026: The Court Rejects a Gag Order

Perry-Bond rejects defendant Diego Sarabia’s request to restrict public statements by the parties and their lawyers. His attorneys argue that publicity threatens a fair proceeding. The judge finds the showing insufficient to justify limiting speech and urges counsel to cooperate in protecting people from threats and harassment.

October 20, 2026: A Separate Defendant Is Dropped

The parties agree to dismiss Orazio Petito from the lawsuit with prejudice after he was incorrectly identified as Chi Phi’s president at the time of the alleged incident. Petito was not one of the seven men accused of sexual misconduct, and his dismissal doesn’t resolve the claims against them.

October 22, 2026: James’ Office Defends Her Appointment

Lawyers for James and Hochul ask the court to reject Lopes’ challenge. They argue that James’ post expressed empathy rather than prejudgment and that his concerns about a potential prosecution are premature. The filing seeks dismissal of the challenge, not dismissal of Doe’s civil lawsuit.

October 23, 2026: Anonymity Is Granted As Sarabia Seeks Dismissal

Perry-Bond rules that Doe can continue under a pseudonym, citing the case’s notoriety and harassment. The same day, Sarabia moves to dismiss the claims against him. His lawyer argues that the specific allegations against him do not establish participation in rape and that the claims are untimely. That is a defense argument, not a ruling. 

October 29, 2026: A Judge Hears Arguments on Letitia James’ Role and Cornell Changes How It Handles Sexual Offense Complaints

New York State Supreme Court Justice James Farrell hears arguments in Sullivan County on Gillio Lopes’ request to remove Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor. Lopes’ lawyers argue that James’ social media post supporting Doe showed bias. The state argues that the harm Lopes anticipates has yet to occur. Farrell questions how removing James at Lopes’ request would affect the investigation of the other six men. He holds off on ruling and gives Lopes’ lawyers until November 5 to clarify whether the others will join the petition.

Also on October 29, Cornell signs an agreement with New York State Police to refer sexual offense complaints that would ordinarily go to campus police to state police for criminal investigation, unless the person reporting requests another agency. The agreement takes effect immediately and will remain in place while Sally Yates reviews the university’s handling of sexual misconduct.

November 4, 2026: Jacqueline Kelly Is Named to Lead the Criminal Investigation

James appoints former federal prosecutor Jacqueline Kelly as outside counsel to lead the reopened investigation. Kelly’s team will gather evidence, review earlier investigative records and interview witnesses. The team will report to the attorney general’s office, which remains the appointed special prosecutor.

November 5, 2026: 4 More Defendants Agree to Join Lopes’ Petition

At the deadline set by Justice James Farrell, Lopes’ lawyers ask the court to add four men to his petition seeking James’ removal. Diego Sarabia, Scott Kretzschmar and Winston Lee support her removal. Scott Norris agrees to join and reserves the right to participate. Matthew Ingalls and Johnathan Newell have given no response as of the filing. The lawsuit remains pending alongside the criminal investigation at the time of publication.

Beyond the Headlines: Sexual Assault and Child Custody

Experts discuss the challenges women face after becoming pregnant through sexual assault and fighting their rapists for custody in court.

Related Features:

Ken Urker and Gypsy Rose Blanchard’s Relationship From Prison Letters to Parenthood

The pair, who began as prison pen pals, welcomed a daughter in December 2024.

5m read

The Allan and Catherine Kassenoff Custody Battle: What Happened?

Their custody dispute became an online sensation.

7m read

Lindsay Clancy Case: Will the Massachusetts Mom Face Retrial?

Clancy admitted she killed her three children in January 2023.

7m read

The Harlem Park Three: How 3 Men Were Exonerated After 36 Years

Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart and Ransom Watkins were convicted of DeWitt Duckett's murder.

6m read

About the author

Bella Czajkowski

Bella Czajkowski is a journalist based in Brooklyn, N.Y. She covers primarily politics, tech and crime. She holds a BA in Public Affairs Journalism from Ohio State University and an MS in investigative reporting from Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism.

More by Author

Fact Check

We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! A&E reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.

Citation Information

Article Title
Who Are the Cornell 7? A Timeline of the Allegations and Investigation
Website Name
A&E
Date Accessed
November 16, 2026
Publisher
A&E Television Networks
Last Updated
November 16, 2026
Original Published Date
November 16, 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement