The Evidence of Ruby Franke's Child Abuse
The neighbor was shocked by the physical state of the escaped boy. His wrists and ankles were duct-taped, and he was severely malnourished. He asked for food, water and police assistance. The neighbor complied, giving the child pretzels and candy while placing a 911 call.
Eric Clarke, the Washington County Attorney who oversaw the Franke child abuse case, says that the boy's "most horrific injuries" were "open wounds" on his wrists and ankles from being handcuffed.
"If you watch the [police body cam footage] from that day, [Franke and Hildebrandt] did a homeopathic remedy on his wounds—put cayenne pepper and honey into them," Clarke tells A&E Crime + Investigation. "They put cayenne pepper into his wounds, wrapped it in Saran wrap, wrapped that in duct tape and then handcuffed and tied him up."
The footage can be seen in a digital exclusive episode of A&E's Crime in Progress.
Where the Abuse Took Place
After getting a search warrant for Hildebrandt's house, investigators went into the home and discovered another one of Franke's children: an emaciated 10-year-old girl. Perhaps most incriminating, investigators found a diary that Franke had kept for two months detailing the punishments she had doled out over the summer, at the Hildebrandt home.
According to Clarke, those punishments included making her children stand outside in the desert heat all day.
"It's very hot here in June. We're 100 miles from Las Vegas," Clarke explains, adding that the boy was made to stand on a concrete patio with no food or water—and was punished when he tried to seek shade. "There was clear evidence that the kids' skin had peeled repeatedly. The most shocking part [in reading the diaries] is how convinced Ruby was that what she was doing was right."
Clarke says that Franke and the children ended up at Hildebrandt's home through an escalating series of events. First, Hildebrandt had been a family therapist serving the Frankes; she later became a marriage counselor to Franke and her husband. When the couple separated, Hildebrandt entered into a business partnership with Franke, working on ConneXions, a life coaching service.
Franke moved into the Hildebrandt home in May 2023, a few months before the arrests.
The Sentencing of Ruby Franke
For her crimes, Franke pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated child abuse and received a sentence of four to 30 years in prison. Hildebrandt received the same sentence. Their initial hearing before the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole is scheduled for December 2026.
Clarke thinks Franke and Hildebrandt shouldn't be released "until both minor children are adults."
Some critics believe Franke's sentencing came too late. In 2020, an online petition of “8 Passengers” viewers, with thousands of signatures, urged Utah Child Protective Services to get involved.
Takkeem Morgan, a spokesperson at the nonprofit Prevent Child Abuse America tells A&E Crime + Investigation that the government's failure to intervene on behalf of the children earlier points to systemic issues in how child abuse cases are handled.
"Wealth and social status can delay or prevent intervention," Morgan says, adding that the "public perception" of Franke as an influencer "masked severe abuse."
Clarke says the abuses that did or didn't happen on the “8 Passengers” channel prior to the Hildebrandt abuse was irrelevant to his case, because Franke's home in Utah County—where those videos were all filmed—fell outside his jurisdiction. But he urges parents to be cautious with the way they expose their children to the outside eyes of an Internet audience.
"A lot of parents will post social media of, say, their kids on the beach at family vacation," he says. "There's obviously a huge difference between that and sensationalizing your parenting for the sake of a [social media] channel. But everyone should be careful in how you utilize your kids for social media."
Clarke feels Franke and Hildebrandt "were actively hiding these kids" from the public, indicating a problem.
"They knew that what they were doing was wrong," he continues. "If you're not comfortable telling your neighbors about [the type of parenting] you're doing, then you probably need to stop doing it."